Wandering Thoughts archives


The (peculiar) freedom of having a slow language

Back in my entry on why speeding up (C)Python matters, I said in an aside that there was a peculiar freedom in having a slow language. Today I'm going to explain what I meant in that cryptic aside.

The peculiar freedom of having a slow language is the mirror image of the peculiar constraint of having a fast language, which is that in a fast language there is usually a (social) pressure to write fast code. Maybe not the very fastest code that you could, that's premature optimization, but at least code that is not glaringly under-performant. When the language provides you a fast way to do what your code needs to do, you're supposed to use it. Usually this means using a 'narrow' feature, one that is not particularly more powerful than you need.

In a slow language like (C)Python, you are free of this constraint. You don't have to feel guilty about using an 'expensive' feature or operation to deal with a small problem instead of carefully writing some narrow efficient code. The classical example of this is various sorts of simple parsing. In many languages, using a regular expression to do most parsing is vastly indulgent because it's comparatively slow, even if it leads to simple and short code; there is great social pressure to write hand-rolled character inspection code and the like. In CPython you can use regexps here without any guilt; not only are they comparatively fast, they're probably faster than hand written code that does it the hard way.

The result of this is that in CPython I solve a lot of problems with simple brute force using builtins, regular expressions, and other broad powerful features, while in languages like Go I wind up writing more complicated, more verbose code that is more narrow and more efficient because it only does what's strictly necessary.

(I came to really be aware of this after recently writing some Go code to turn newlines into CR NL sequences as I was writing output to the network. In Python this is a one-liner piece of code; in Go, the 'right' Go-y way involves a carefully efficient hand-rolled loop, even though you could theoretically do it in exactly the same way that Python does.)

python/SlowLanguageFreedom written at 02:07:37; Add Comment

Page tools: See As Normal.
Login: Password:
Atom Syndication: Recent Pages, Recent Comments.

This dinky wiki is brought to you by the Insane Hackers Guild, Python sub-branch.