2024-10-03
(Unix) daemonization turns out to be quite old
In the Unix context, 'daemonization' means a program that totally detaches itself from how it was started. It was once very common and popular, but with modern init systems they're often no longer considered to be all that good an idea. I have some views on the history here, but today I'm going to confine myself to a much smaller subject, which is that in Unix, daemonization goes back much further than I expected. Some form of daemonization dates to Research Unix V5 or earlier, and an almost complete version appears in network daemons in 4.2 BSD.
As far back as Research Unix V5 (from 1974), /etc/rc is starting
/etc/update (which does a periodic sync()
) without explicitly
backgrounding it. This is the giveaway sign that 'update
' itself
forks and exits in the parent, the initial version of daemonization,
and indeed that's what we find in update.s (it
wasn't yet a C program). The V6 update is still in assembler, but
now the V6 update.s is
clearly not just forking but also closing file descriptors 0, 1,
and 2.
In the V7 /etc/rc, the new /etc/cron is also started without being explicitly put into the background. The V7 update.c seems to be a straight translation into C, but the V7 cron.d has a more elaborate version of daemonization. V7 cron forks, chdir's to /, does some odd things with standard input, output, and error, ignores some signals, and then starts doing cron things. This is pretty close to what you'd do in modern daemonization.
The first 'network daemons' appeared around the time of 4.2 BSD. The 4.2BSD /etc/rc explicitly backgrounds all of the r* daemons when it starts them, which in theory means they could have skipped having any daemonization code. In practice, rlogind.c, rshd.c, rexecd.c, and rwhod.c all have essentially identical code to do daemonization. The rlogind.c version is:
#ifndef DEBUG if (fork()) exit(0); for (f = 0; f < 10; f++) (void) close(f); (void) open("/", 0); (void) dup2(0, 1); (void) dup2(0, 2); { int tt = open("/dev/tty", 2); if (tt > 0) { ioctl(tt, TIOCNOTTY, 0); close(tt); } } #endif
This forks with the parent exiting (detaching the child from the process hierarchy), then the child closes any (low-numbered) file descriptors it may have inherited, sets up non-working standard input, output, and error, and detaches itself from any controlling terminal before starting to do rlogind's real work. This is pretty close to the modern version of daemonization.
(Today, the ioctl() stuff is done by calling setsid() and you'd probably want to close more than the first ten file descriptors, although that's still a non-trivial problem.)