Wandering Thoughts archives

2020-01-15

Stopping udev from renaming your VLAN interfaces to bad names

Back in early December I wrote about Why udev may be trying to rename your VLAN interfaces to bad names, where modern versions of udev tried to rename VLAN devices from the arbitrary names you give them to the base name of the network device they're on. Since the base name is already taken, this fails.

There turns out to be a simple cause and workaround for this, at least in my configuration, from Zbigniew Jędrzejewski-Szmek. In Fedora, all I need to do is add 'NamePolicy=keep' to the [Link] section of my .link file. This makes my .link file be:

[Match]
MACAddress=60:45:cb:a0:e8:dd

[Link]
Description=Onboard port
MACAddressPolicy=persistent
Name=em0
# Stop VLAN renaming
NamePolicy=keep

Setting 'NamePolicy=keep' doesn't keep the actual network device from being renamed from the kernel's original name for it to 'em0', but it makes udev leave the VLAN devices alone. In turn this means udev and systemd consider them to have been successfully created, so you get the usual systemd sys-subsystem-net-devices .devices units for them showing up as fully up.

In a way, 'NamePolicy=keep' in a .link file is an indirect way for me to tell apart real network hardware from created virtual devices that share the same MAC, or at least ones created through networkd. As covered in the systemd.netdev manpage, giving a name to your virtual device is mandatory (Name= is a required field), so I think such devices will always be considered to already have a name by udev.

(This was a change in systemd-241, apparently. It changes the semantics of existing .link files in a way that's subtly not backward compatible, but such is the systemd way.)

However, I suspect that things might be different if I didn't use 'biosdevname=0' in my kernel command line parameters. These days this is implemented in udev, so allowing udev to rename your network devices from the kernel assigned names to the consistent network device naming scheme may be considered a rename for the purposes of 'NamePolicy=keep'. That would leave me with the same problem of telling real hardware apart from virtual hardware that I had in the original entry.

However, for actual matching against physical hardware, I suspect that you can also generally use a Property= on selected attributes (as suggested by Alex Xu in the comments on the original entry). For instance, most people's network devices are on PCI busses, so:

Property=ID_BUS=pci

There are a whole variety of properties that real network hardware has that VLANs don't (based on 'udev info' output), although I don't know about other types of virtual network devices. It does seem pretty safe that no virtual network device will claim to be on a PCI bus, though.

(I haven't tested the Property= approach, since 'NamePolicy=keep' is sufficient in my case.)

UdevNetworkdVLANLinkMatchingII written at 00:42:43; Add Comment


Page tools: See As Normal.
Search:
Login: Password:
Atom Syndication: Recent Pages, Recent Comments.

This dinky wiki is brought to you by the Insane Hackers Guild, Python sub-branch.