Modern HDDs have gotten somewhat better than they used to be

June 20, 2022

I tweeted:

I didn't expect these spinning rust HDs to be able to sustain 235 Mbyte/sec read and write rates (sequential IO, it's software RAID building/resynching). I guess large, high-density drives have improved the 150 MB/sec I used to expect.

I haven't paid attention to the spinning rust hard drive industry for a while (long enough that I missed the terminology switch from 'HD' to 'HDD'). Generally at work, our use of HDDs is limited to either unimportant servers where we're going through our old stock of 'smaller' HDDs to use them as system drives, or for bulk storage, generally using older drives, where we don't really pay close attention to read and write speeds.

Recently we got some 20 TB HDDs to become the future data storage for our Prometheus metrics system, which is outgrowing its current mirrored pair of 4 TB HDDs. For reasons somewhat beyond the scope of this entry, I'm not doing an in-place storage upgrade; instead I put the 20 TBs into the new Ubuntu 22.04 server that will take over as our Prometheus server and built a Linux software RAID mirror. When you build new Linux software RAID mirrors, they need to resync. I was curious to how long this would take, so I looked at /proc/mdstat, which gave me both an estimated time (which amounted to about 24 hours) and a current data rate, which it said was around 220,000K/sec.

At first I assumed that this data rate was an initial burst rate that would soon fall. But we have Prometheus metrics for this host, and several hours later they confirmed that it really was sustaining these data rates; in fact, they'd increased up to what I tweeted. One of the two 20 TBs is reading at this speed and the other is writing at it, and they're both sustaining it (in fact, Linux disk stats also claim that neither disk is 100% utilized).

When I checked the specification sheet for this drive series, this is unsurprisingly under their quoted maximum speed (claimed to be 269 decimal MB/s, because of course disk vendors quote everything in the smaller SI units). According to the specifications sheet (okay, "product brief"), these good data rates hold right down to the 4 TB model (at 255 MB/s), and even the 2TB and 1TB models claim higher sustained rates than I'm used to (of 200 MB/s and 184 MB/s).

Now that I've looked, this is also not exclusive to this model line from this vendor. It seems that all of the 20 TB HDDs we looked at quote similar data transfer rates, and probably do so even for smaller models (I haven't looked extensively). Apparently the days of assuming only 150 to 160 Mbyte/sec of sustained read and write performance on your HDDs are over (although we still have plenty of them that only perform that well).

(I have no idea if there's been any improvement in IOPS/second, which on HDDs is more or less seeks per second. Since they're still 7200 RPM, I suspect that it's basically the same as always.)

Written on 20 June 2022.
« What fast SSH bulk transfer speed (probably) looks like in mid-2022
Some network speeds and network related speeds we see in mid 2022 »

Page tools: View Source, Add Comment.
Login: Password:
Atom Syndication: Recent Comments.

Last modified: Mon Jun 20 22:01:20 2022
This dinky wiki is brought to you by the Insane Hackers Guild, Python sub-branch.