Why a laptop is not likely to be my primary machine any time soon

February 6, 2010

I know and read a number of people who use laptops as their primary machines, but I'm one of the people who's not interested in the idea (even ignoring any issues of relative prices). I wound up actually thinking about the question recently, and as it turns out I think I have a fairly odd set of reasons for it.

So, here they are so far:

  • I have very particular tastes in keyboards (I have used a BTC-5100C keyboard for more than a decade) and for the space immediately in front of the keyboard. Laptops may have decent keyboards, but they don't have my keyboard.

  • I want a fairly physically large display with good resolution, especially good vertical resolution; when there's room for it, I want two of them.

  • I use two drives in my systems in order to have mirrored (system) disks. (Of course this can have drawbacks.)

In the past, my desire for Unix (ideally Linux) would also have been a significant obstacle, but my impression is that it's now relatively easy to find a nice modern laptop that has good Linux support. (Hopefully I'm not wrong.)

Another way of thinking about this is that I have two roles for computers: the computer I sit in front of all the time, and the computer that I take places for relatively moderate use. For the heavily used computer, I have strong and very particular opinions about the pieces of the computer that I interact with a lot (the keyboard, the displays), but I'm indifferent to the rest of it (provided that it's quiet). I don't care as much about the casual computer, but I want it to be small, light, and still nice for productive work.

(The late Dell Mini 12 is about my platonic ideal of the casual laptop in form factor, screen resolution, and keyboard.)

It's pretty clear to me that some of these desires clash even in the best of circumstances, particularly the displays; a laptop screen big enough to be one of my regular displays makes the laptop too big to be conveniently portable. Thus, if I tried to use a laptop for both roles the only use I'd get for it in the full time usage role would be as the system unit of a desktop system, as I wouldn't use either its display or its keyboard (and I'd still only have one system disk). If I absolutely had to have only computer this could be workable, but if not, there's little advantage to it.

I suspect that other people are generally much less particular and picky about their keyboards, displays, software, and so on. (Or, alternately, they have found a laptop maker whose keyboards and screens they are as fond of as I am fond of my favorites.)

(This entry was sparked by the discussion here. Plus, I feel like not writing about documentation for days on end.)

Comments on this page:

From at 2010-02-06 06:25:10:

The primary reasons why I bought a Samsung NC10 and not any other netbook or small laptop were keyboard and battery life. (It’s not perfect: it has a touchpad rather than a trackpoint. But I couldn’t find any netbook that has a trackpoint. For some reason I found the tiny screen is much less of an issue than I anticipated, though.) And I spent several days trying to find a vendor who’d ship a unit with a US layout keyboard to Germany before I gave up and bought a German layout unit. (Which reminds me, I should check whether I can buy a separate US-layout NC10 keyboard now…)

Over time, I’ve spent some US$300 on keyboards before finding the perfect one for me. I even suffered through kernel tweaking required by Apple’s USB ID shenanigans to make it work, I’m that fastidious about the feel and size of a keyboard.

At the office at Uni, the machines are Dell boxes, and they come with Dell keyboards. Any time I am at the office (I mostly work at home) and have to work on one of those I hate it after just 3 minutes. Most of the time I just work on the NC10 instead.

Aristotle Pagaltzis

From at 2010-02-07 00:12:01:

Personally, I have the laptop up on a stand to make it eye level, and an external keyboard and mouse of my choice. When I can, I plug in a second monitor...

Best of both worlds as far as I'm concerned.

From at 2010-02-09 20:48:48:

To make plugging in to a 'stand' or whatnot easier, use a port replicator (docking station). Nearly every regular-sized laptop offers one. I arrive at work, plop my lappie on the dock and hit the external power button - the lid never gets raised, and I spend my day using the computer as if it's a desktop.

Not trying to convince you though, since there are a number of hardware-related reasons to not use a laptop.

Written on 06 February 2010.
« Emergency procedures checklists need check steps
The problem with blog footnotes »

Page tools: View Source, View Normal, Add Comment.
Login: Password:
Atom Syndication: Recent Comments.

Last modified: Sat Feb 6 00:44:34 2010
This dinky wiki is brought to you by the Insane Hackers Guild, Python sub-branch.